StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Euthyphro Dilemma according to Plato and Socrates - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Euthyphro Dilemma according to Plato and Socrates" paper engages a discussion of the highlights of the work as well as seeks to draw a level of inference with regards to what if any, final definition of holiness/piety can be drawn from the back-and-forth discussions of Socrates and Plato…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Euthyphro Dilemma according to Plato and Socrates
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Euthyphro Dilemma according to Plato and Socrates"

?In seeking to answer the underlying question of what defines piety/holiness, Plato presents the quandary that Socrates finds himself; charged with the capital crime of impiety. In representing this situation, Plato hinges his discussion upon the back and forth between Euthyphro and Socrates as the two men discuss what typifies piety and how it is represented within the world. The following analysis will briefly engage a discussion of the highlights of the work as well as seek to draw a level of inference with regards to what, if any, final definition of holiness/piety can be drawn from the back and forth discussions of these two men. In the beginning of the work, Socrates is shocked that one could take their father to trial on charges of manslaughter; deeming it to be so far outside the conventions of the law and of society that it is almost incomprehensible morally and/or judicially. Euthyphro, on the other hand, focuses on the piety of the son and courage that he must have had in order to perform such an action; referening the fact that a universal belief in goodness and the justice of the rule of law overcame even the strict moral dictates of respect. Exemplifying Socratic irony, Socrates states that he wishes to learn from Euthyphro concerning piety so that he might use this to defend himself against the trial that awaits him (Reed, 2013). The conversation that follows between the two develops, expands and allows the reader to come to a more full and informed understanding of how logical thought concerning piety and/or holiness can be informed as a result of the trial of Socrates; the situation that of course prompted the entire work to be written in the first place. The central question that is asked is ultimately what defines piety. Socrates understandably seeks such a definition due to the fact that he is forced to defend himself on charges of impiety and reasonably seeks something of a universal dictum and/or definition that he can use as a means of defending himself against the charges made. In search of this “universal paradigm” for defining goodness and holiness, Socrates and Euthyphro have a conversation and debate that discusses various aspects of piety/holiness. The first argument that is put forward by Euthyphro offers the understanding that piety is represented in the exemplification of the son taking his father to trial for manslaughter. Socrates understandably appreciates this; however, he rejects it due to the fact that it a piety cannot be defined by a pious action alone. As such, Euthyphro offers Socrates a second definition; namely that, “Piety is what is pleasing to the gods”. Socrates enjoys and appreciates this definition initially as well; however, this of course leads to the regression of the fact that it is difficult for mankind to know what is pleasing to the gods and the gods themselves even disagree with regards to what is pleasing. Likewise, Socrates pushes Euthyphro a bit further for a more universal and easily applicable definition of what piety and/or holiness means in such a context As a means of offering yet another exemplification/definition, Euthyphro states that in order to categorize this in the way that Socrates desires, it must be necessary to view the argument as whatever all the gods love is pious and whatever all the gods hate is impious. Socrates answers this by introducing what he refers to as the Euthyphro dilemma; namely questioning whether what is pious is loved by the gods based upon the fact that it is pious, or is it pious based upon the fact that it is loved by the gods. Likewise, the fourth definition is offered; stating that piety is a direct outgrowth of justice. This fourth definition deviates from the others due to the fact that it is presented not by Euthyphro but by Socrates. Most interestingly, piety and holiness have gone from what can be defined and understood from the gods to what can be defined and understood based upon the law of man (Mounce, 2013). This naturally references the ultimate debacle that Socrates finds himself in. Due to the fact that Socrates finds it impossible to know the will and likes/dislikes of the gods, the only measurement for piety/holiness that he can reasonably incur is with regards to the virtues of the man-made laws of justice and goodness. The final discussion comes full circle as Euthyphro yet again references the degree and extent to which the gods approval and “like” define piety. This occurs just before Socrates is due to appear before his tribunal facing the charges of impiety. The inability of these two men to come to a level of understanding and mutual agreement with regards to what defines piety/holiness is indicative, as it was intended to be, of the situation that Socrates faced. Few individuals, other than Socrates himself, were willing or able to come to a realization that piety/holiness was a difficult topic to define and seeking to charge an individual upon a crime of impiety ultimately digressed into a situation in which personal views of what defined it would come to be the deciding factors (Sharpe, 2010). What is referenced by these altering, yet keenly inter-related definitions, is the fact that piety/holiness is a difficult concept to pin down in a universal sense. Rather than running the reader through a list of definitions that are ultimately flawed and leaving one to determine that one particular definition of piety is best suited towards understanding piety/holiness in a universalist sense, Plato instead delineates that piety/holiness is something of a relative concept and cannot likely be understood by any mere mortal. Stopping far short of saying that a level of moral relativity defines the world in which we live, Plato instead intimates that the foolishness of the entire situation hinges upon the fact that it is ultimately unfair that anyone should be tried for a crime of impiety due to the fact that no clear definition of it exists and any human understanding, which has thus far been reasonably well presented, falls short of working in a universal context. References Mounce, D. (2013). Euthyphro dilemma. The British Journal Of General Practice: The Journal Of The Royal College Of General Practitioners, 63(611), 293. doi:10.3399/bjgp13X668131 Reed, R. (2013). Euthyphro's Elenchus Experience: Ethical Expertise and Self-Knowledge. Ethical Theory & Moral Practice,16(2), 245-259. doi:10.1007/s10677-012-9335-x SHARPE, M. (2010). Uncovering Euthyphro's Treasure. Helios, 37(1), 23-48. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Euthyphro : Plato Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486290-euthyphro-yt-plato
(Euthyphro : Plato Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486290-euthyphro-yt-plato.
“Euthyphro : Plato Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1486290-euthyphro-yt-plato.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Euthyphro Dilemma according to Plato and Socrates

Euthyphro: Plato's Early Dialogues

according to plato, he argued that what is right or piety is defined without any reference to the gods.... This argument elicits a contemporary criticism of the purpose of morality and God's command rooted in the euthyphro dilemma.... The focus of the paper "Euthyphro: Plato's Early Dialogues" is on Plato's dialogue, the Euthyphro, socrates, moral perception, morality or piety, gods' commands, the perception that Gods will is the basis in determining morality, theological voluntarism, an arbitrary role of God's power....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The dilema socrates and euthyphro finds themselves in

Thus, the dialogue between Euthyphro and socrates is a logic line of reasoning coming, first, to a dilemma and followed by the final argument.... Piety follows after the sacrifice and prayer in terms of what the gods like and dislike according to a definite situation.... At this point, here comes the “euthyphro dilemma,” so to speak.... The talk on piety represented by socrates and Euthyphro gives grounds to making a set of arguments on what should be related to this very concept....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Life and Its Lessons

socrates said that he doesn't want to flee, though he was to be sentenced.... t was also in the text “Apology” wherein the “Strong Promise of Defiance” showed that socrates was willing to defy the Athenian court whether it was a legal or illegal order if it stops him from being what he is which is a philosopher....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Euthyphro : Plato

Euthyphro-Plato Name Institution Euthyphro-Plato In Plato's dialogue, Euthyphro and socrates present an argument against a common moral perception that morality or piety is a matter of what the gods' commands it is.... Unfortunately, this definition of holiness or piety is strongly rejected by Socrates because he does not agree with Euthyphro as according to him, the gods may not agree among themselves.... This argument elicits a contemporary criticism of the purpose of morality and God's command rooted in the euthyphro dilemma....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Moral Relativism and Plato’s Euthyphro

The first great critic of relativism was plato himself.... Similarly, there are lots of perspectives regarding the role or identity of truth.... Truth can be ‘subjective', objective', ‘relative' or ‘absolute'.... The idea that the truth is relative implies that.... ... ... Dooyeweerd's contention of truth focuses on the relative aspects of truth....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Text and tradition

Euthyphro formulates the definition according to which piety is intervened with sacrificing and praying.... The dialogue between socrates and Euthryphro aims to distinguish whether rational understanding of the concept of piety, holiness and Gods in generally is possible.... socrates, in turn, rejects such option, explaining that this is rather the example of piety than the definition.... Then Euthypro suggests another formulation: piety is the thing which is socrates objects, pointing to existence of various Gods and, as a result, different ways of pleasing them; there is a logical contradiction when one the same action can be represented at the same time pious and improper: ...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Socrates on Unexamined Life

The paper "socrates on Unexamined Life" explains that socrates is remarkably renowned for his claim over whether he was not appropriate living an unexamined life.... The later philosophers after socrates' time had different opinions about the approach to life.... socrates is prominent as one of the elite philosophers of his time for shaping the intellectual and cultural development of the world.... socrates insistence on this claim portrays that human beings are born or called to reflect upon their beliefs, speak to seek out, account for what they do not know and know, live accordance to their views and defend those beliefs that make a meaningful and well-lived life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Challenges of the Divine Command Theory

This theory has in the past and at present provided the basis for volumes of critical works, with philosophers such as plato and Nielsen having criticized it based on it being forced upon those who do not believe in supreme beings (Nielsen, 1973).... The paper "Challenges of the Divine Command Theory" analyzes and discusses the problems associated with divine command theory....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us