StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The two cases Carvaho v. tool brothers developer and Herczeng v. haptom township municpal - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Instructor 9th May 2011 Fine Points In Jobsite Safety Cases The aim of this study: To appreciate how legal cases of almost similar nature in this case jobsite safety can call for totally different and unexpected verdicts. This essay will try to highlight what key differences have produced the different outcomes…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
The two cases Carvaho v. tool brothers developer and Herczeng v. haptom township municpal
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The two cases Carvaho v. tool brothers developer and Herczeng v. haptom township municpal"

9th May Fine Points In Jobsite Safety Cases The aim of this study: To appreciate how legal cases of almost similar nature in this case jobsite safety can call for totally different and unexpected verdicts. This essay will try to highlight what key differences have produced the different outcomes. Case No: 1. Cidalina O. Carvalho, etc. v. Toll Brothers and Developers, et al. (A-35-95) The Accident: The West Windsor Township had contracted with Toll Brothers and Developers for the construction of sewer service to Assunpink Basin with Bergman Hatton Engineering Associates as engineers.

Francisco Caravalho, an employee of the subcontractor Jude Enterprises who was doing the excavation work, died when an unshored portion of the trench he was working in collapsed. [Handler] Argument The prosecution charged that Bergman’s site inspector hired to observe the work performed and who was present when the accident happened to monitor the progress of the work had a duty to supervise safety procedures of the construction and that the inspector had knowledge of the unsafe condition. Responding to the suit by the widow, Mrs.

Carvalho, Bergman said maintained that the engineer's contract disclaimed responsibility for jobsite safety [which the court allowed].The methods, the interpretation, and the enforcement of hold harmless agreements should be governed by the intention of the parties in providing for insurance and the division of risk. [Handler].The site inspector’s duty was limited to inspect only the material being used and the amount of work being done. The rationale behind this defense was obviously the trust of the defense in the “hold harmless clause” in the defendant’s contract.

He also noted because of an error he was not insured. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court instead did a "multi-dimensional" analysis and held an engineer has a legal duty to exercise reasonable care for the safety of workers on a construction site when the engineer has a contractual responsibility for the progress of the work, but not for safety conditions, yet can forsee danger. The following grounds were discovered. Direct Supervision and approval of daily work progress was the contractual obligation of the engineer.

As there was a cave-in only 200 yards from the accident location, a week before and since trench boxes were in use the previous three days, the engineer knew of the unstable condition, yet took no action to forestall danger. [Camilleri]. Therefore, the financial arrangements and understanding do not overcome the public policy that imposes a duty of care and ascribes liability to the engineer in these circumstances. [Handler p.7] .This case set a precedent for professional liability for engineers.

Case 2: Herczeg v. Hampton Township Municipal Authority and Bankson Engineers, Inc. (2010) In February of 1995, Hampton Township? Municipal Authority engaged Bankson Engineers for a project with Allison Park Inc as Contractors. On March 20, 1995, Stephen M. Wagner ,an employee was working in an unshored trench approximately seven feet deep laying pipe when a cave-in occurred fatally injuring him. He succumbed to death two months later [Findlaw]. Bankson had a professional as site inspector and lack of shoring was in violation to Bankson’s own regulations.

The prosecution charged that Bankson's representative had actual knowledge that the employee working in a dangerously unsafe trench and serious injury or death was reasonably foreseeable and Bankson is thus responsible for death of Mr. Wagner. Bankson replied that it had no knowledge of an unsafe condition, no duty regarding the allegations and that none of its services were involved in the cause of the accident. Bankson alleged that it had no direct control the contractor's work or any responsibility for job site safety.

[Pro-Form] KEY DIFFERENCE: The judge allowing Bankson’s argument noted that unlike in Carvalho, Bankson did not have stop-work authority, did not have daily supervision of the jobsite making them accountable, or any previous knowledge of trench collapse to forsee the danger.[Crow] Works Cited Camilleri- Camilleri & Clarke Associates - Civil Engineer Pays the Price for Inaction. Jobsite Safety, Part 1 A/E Risk Review, www.camillericlarke.com. Camilleri & Clarke Associates. Web. 9 May 2011. URL: www.

camillericlarke.com/newsletters/.files/68-aeJobsiteSafety1.pdf Crow –Crow Friedman Group.Jobsite Safety.Part I: Liabilities Get Muddy.Volume 3 Issue 3 ww.crowfriedman.com .Crow Friedman Group. July 2008 Web 9 May 2011 URL: www.crowfriedman.com/pdf/newsletter_0708.pdf Handler – Handler. J. Carvalho v. Toll Bros. and Developers 5/6/1996. www.napil.com. National Association of the Personal injury Lawyers, Pages 1-7.5 May 1996. Web.9 May 2011 http://www.napil.com/PersonalInjuryCaseLawDetail30357.

htm Pro-Form – Pro-form Insurance. Jobsite Safety. Part 1: Liabilities Get Muddy. Page 1. www.proforminsurance.ca. Pro-Form Insurance Services. 10 Sept 2008. Web.9 May 2011. www.proforminsurance.ca/docs/sept08newsletterpt1.pdf - Findlaw- Findlaw .Herczeg V. Hampton Township Municipal Authority. Para 2. Web. 9 May 2011. http://caselaw.findlaw.com/pa-superior-court/1218333.html

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The two cases Carvaho v. tool brothers developer and Herczeng v Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1419620-the-two-cases-carvaho-v-tool-brothers-developer
(The Two Cases Carvaho V. Tool Brothers Developer and Herczeng V Essay)
https://studentshare.org/other/1419620-the-two-cases-carvaho-v-tool-brothers-developer.
“The Two Cases Carvaho V. Tool Brothers Developer and Herczeng V Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1419620-the-two-cases-carvaho-v-tool-brothers-developer.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The two cases Carvaho v. tool brothers developer and Herczeng v. haptom township municpal

Developed Musical Event in Albert Park

The paper "Developed Musical Event in Albert Park" describes that the specific musical event has many chances to be successful especially if it is appropriately planned.... The role of the project planner is significant, it can be compared with the role of the leader within modern organizations....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study

Big Brother Bart

the two chosen theories here are Utilitarianism and Deontology.... Bart's manager requests him to use this software to keep track of two specific employees who are under the suspicion of trading in drugs using the office computers.... The paper "Big Brother Bart" aims at discussing one such case of Bart a systems analyst....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers

This case study "Bankruptcy of Lehman brothers" discusses Detail the accounting technique presented in the case Lehman brothers.... hellip; The collapse of Lehman brothers Holdings, Inc.... nbsp;The study considers two accounting treatments applicable.... rdquo;, providing two accounting treatments applicable to such transfers....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Developmental Analysis: My Brothers Cases

"Developmental Analysis: My brothers' Cases" paper summarizes the case of the author's brothers and states the theories of developmental stages as explained by Ericson, Freud, Maslow, and Piaget.... t is a common observation that despite the fact that parents have provided the same parental care techniques under the same environment to each of their children, there will always be a very high tendency that our brothers and sisters will behave differently from us....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Bankruptcy in Lehman Brothers

This paper "Bankruptcy in Lehman brothers" discusses Lehman brothers, a 150-year-old global investment bank that shocked many people worldwide, when the organization declared bankruptcy in September 2008.... hellip; Though these incidents occurred gradually, the top management of the Lehman brothers did not heed the risk assessment reports presented by the experts of the risk.... The collapse of Lehman brothers has put the huge workforce out of work, wiping out billions of dollars in personal net worth, and an estimated $600 billion loss in stock market value worldwide (Jenny, 2008, pp 43-45)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Toll Brothers - Corporate Social Responsibility

This paper "Toll brothers - Corporate Social Responsibility" focuses on one of the dominating home-building companies in the US founded in the 1960s.... This rate of success makes Toll brothers to become a company everyone in American society looks up to in a high level of social responsibility.... nbsp;… In addition to securing the homes of their customers, Toll brothers have also taken a gigantic step to preserve the environment outside these homes....
13 Pages (3250 words) Case Study

Routines and Capabilities of Warner Brothers Entertainment

From the paper "Routines and Capabilities of Warner brothers Entertainment" it is clear that The capabilities of the corporation will increase in the number of projects which can be done, the number of individuals which can work in the full-time contract.... hellip; For Warner brothers, the organizational structure is one which carries several capabilities.... The finances that contribute to Warner brothers are based on selling the entertainment products that are a part of the corporation....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Lehman Brothers

The author of this case study "Lehman brothers" comments on the story “Lehman's Shell Game: Poor Risk Management” in which the accounting technique used by Lehman brothers known as the Repo 105 used fraudulent means to overvalue the firm's financial position to the outside world.... nbsp;It is observed that Lehman brothers through the use of Repo 105 and Repo 108 carried out fraudulent transactions.... Lehman brothers Accounting Technique used by Lehman brothers As unraveled in the story, “Lehman's Shell Game: Poor Risk Management”, the accounting technique used by Lehman brothers known as the Repo 105 used fraudulent means to overvalue the firm's financial position to the outside world....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us