StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Love Juvenile Justice - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Because the U.S Supreme Court has not mandated the right to a jury trial for all juveniles, only 10 states generally allow jury trials as a right for juveniles and another 11 states allow jury trials in special circumstances. Some states contend that it is critical for…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Love Juvenile Justice
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Love Juvenile Justice"

Juveniles Trial by Jury Because the U.S Supreme Court has not man d the right to a jury trial for all juveniles, only 10 states generally allow jury trials as a right for juveniles and another 11 states allow jury trials in special circumstances. Some states contend that it is critical for juveniles to have the right to a jury trial (Whitehead and Lab, 2012). However, I am of the opinion that juveniles should be guaranteed the right to a jury trial. This is for the following reasons.Firstly, a collateral benefit of allowing jury trials is that they may aid rehabilitation.

A juvenile who believes that “the system” has treated him or her unfairly may be less defensive if tried by an objective jury (Elrod and Ryder, 2011, pg. 127). This is to say, a perception of fair treatment may go a long way towards fostering acceptance of responsibility on the part of the juvenile.Secondly, the use of jury trials in delinquency proceedings make a statement to the community and the juvenile regarding the juveniles court’s concern for fundamental due process fairness.Thirdly, unlike in adult courts, the jurors in the juvenile systems are not peers of those on trials.

In some instances, the juvenile may benefit from this fact, because the adults on the jury may remember their own youthful mistakes and indiscretions and feel sympathy (Elrod and Ryder, 2011, pg. 127). If they are parents, jurors also may realize that, under other circumstances, one of their children could be at the defence table. This in as much as may lead to the inclusion of emotions into the final judgement, it eats into the very consciousness of humanity which a jury is supposed to represent.

Finally, Rosenberg (2008) noted that judges generally give a guilty verdict about 25 per cent more often than juries do. This discrepancy is something requiring a level of concern. The American bar association agrees with this finding and concludes that this could as a result of bias from the part of the judges.However, in as much as a trial by the jury is beneficial to the parties involved in any case, but especially the defendant, it also does have some limitations. Jury trials in juvenile proceedings may result to a backlog of cases and hamper the functioning of the juvenile court.

Experience has shown that such trials seriously impede the juvenile justice process (Elrod and Ryder, 2011, pg. 126).Another central issue concerning jury trials for juveniles is the fact that these youth are not tried by a jury of their peers, but a jury of adults. A jury of one’s peers is based on two premises: that the jury be made up of members from the defendants’ community and that the defendant is entitled to an impartial jury (Roesch, Corrado and Dempster, 2001, pg. 53). The process of selecting a jury is a major endeavour, particularly in the American justice system, as the hope of securing an impartial jury is paramount.

A central concern regarding trials for young offenders is that a jury comprised of only adults may hold attitudes about young people that will result in a systematic bias in decision making regarding juveniles defendants as compared to adult defendants (Roesch, Corrado and Dempster, 2001, pg. 53).In my view the composition of the jury should encompass both teens as well as adults. This is because the presence of a teen in the jury presents one of the most powerful motivators in a young person’s life- peer approval and acceptance (Del Carmen and Trulson, 2005, pg. 231). When the youth are sanctioned by their peers, they are much more likely to internalize the harmful impact of their behaviour and change than when sanctioned by adults.

The presence of adult jurors brings about an aspect of maturity and responsible decision making. The adults remembering their own youthful mistakes and indiscretions may be in a position to feel empathy on the defendants as they may be in a position where they can relate to the accusation labelled against the defendant. It is therefore very important that the jury be comprised of both a youth and adults so as to represent two levels of empathy and apparent maturity.Of concern also is the subject of a lenient or harsh sentence from the jury.

Depending on the type of crime, the leniency or harshness of a sentence will depend on the prevailing concerns that are worrying the immediate community from which the defendant hails from. According to Roesch, Corrado and Dempster (2001, pg. 54), there is a widespread overestimation by the general public of the prevalence of youth crime as well as a public belief that youth should be held more accountable for their crimes. This perception according to them results to the sentences passed on to a defendant by their peers to be more than punitive.

Thus, it can be concluded that the extent of the sentence is relative to the prevailing worries of the community and not a decision that can be decided beforehand as going to be linient or harsh.conlusionIn conclusion, in as much as trial by jury for juveniles carries with it some detriments, with it comes an impression of justice, impartiality and fairness and that is all what majority if not all youth defendants request of the justice system.Works CitedDel Carmen, Rolando V and Chad R Trulson.

Juvenile justice: the system, process, and law. illustrated. California: Cengage Learning, 2005.Elrod, Preston and Scott R Ryder. Juvenile Justice: A Social, Historical and Legal Perspective. 3, revised. Ontario: Jones & Bartlett Learning, 2011.Roesch, Ronald , Raymond R Corrado and Rebecca J Dempster. Psychology in the courts: international advances in knowledge. illustrated. New York: Routledge, 2001.Whitehead, John T and Steven P Lab. Juvenile Justice: An Introduction. 7. Massachusetts: Elsevier, 2012.

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Love Juvenile Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Love Juvenile Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1589247-love-juvenile-justice
(Love Juvenile Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Love Juvenile Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1589247-love-juvenile-justice.
“Love Juvenile Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1589247-love-juvenile-justice.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Love Juvenile Justice

Traditional Ways for Juvenile Justice

The paper "Traditional Ways for juvenile justice" discusses that As the shifting of population from the rural areas to urban areas were taking place at the beginning of the 19th century, the idea of treating young children when committing the crime was building.... Before the start of the 20th century, modern advancements were seen in the juvenile justice system by the reformers.... The changes were being made great by the supreme court of the United States regarding the proceeding and protection for the Juvenile, and the system of juvenile justice was shifted to a new height....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Adult and Juvenile Justice System

Adult and juvenile justice System The court system, in the U.... , has two divisions, the juvenile justice System and the Adult Criminal Justice System.... hellip; Adult and juvenile justice System The court system, in the U.... , has two divisions, the juvenile justice System and the Adult Criminal Justice System.... The juvenile justice System developed from the criminal courts systems 100 years ago (Harr, Hess & Orthmann, 2012)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Brain Research Studies and their Significance to the Juvenile Justice System

hellip; With the help of these new technology, scientists are able not only to see which areas of the brain are activated during certain activities, but they also give us more detailed comparisons between different brains. Among the many areas where these new technology are being applied, for example, the study of the juvenile brain is bringing about a very heated debate among legislators and scientists.... In studying the juvenile brain, the use of new technology in the neurosciences have given way to new observations about differences in the structures of human adult brains and human juvenile brains, observations which basically stress the underdevelopment of juvenile brains....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Criminal Justice

This proposal has utilized the latest crime statistics available in stating the magnitude of the juvenile crime problem, and it will show the need for responsible intervention.... A program has been designed to address the needs of the juvenile at risk community.... Albeit we have not yet turned the corner in ameliorating juvenile crime; these numbers represent light at the end of a long dark tunnel.... Reports of juvenile crime dropping are of little consequence in light of the coming demographic surge of juveniles in their crime prone years from dysfunctional families....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Childhood and delinquency

One of the reasons that juvenile arrest rates for violent crime have reached a historic lowest point in 2012 since 1980 (“Juvenile Arrest”) is because we have an effective juvenile justice system.... We are doing it right by having a juvenile justice system, for we are parents to our youth, not their judges and jail guards.... Age discrimination should exist for juvenile delinquents because of their level of cognitive and psychosocial immaturity and because it reduces juvenile crimes....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Juvenile Delinquency and Intervention to Stop Recidivism

The juvenile justice system, therefore, must focus on rehabilitation rather than punishment.... These measures are supposed to help prevent juvenile crimes … Children are abused in different ways and are made deprived of all their childhood happiness.... Such children will be deprived of parent's love and care and will lose a good family environment....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Evolution of the Rights of Juveniles

The present study would focus on the development of the juvenile justice System.... The duration of these lucky seven cases ranges from the year 1966 to 2005 and had a great impact on the juvenile justice system of America.... However, seven juvenile cases are believed to entirely shift the paradigm of the justice system for juveniles in the US.... nbsp;… The juveniles in the American society have already undergone some great changes in their lives as a result of the strong impact of the juvenile cases....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Juvenile Justice in the United States

The paper "juvenile justice in the United States" describes that the system of several nations has greatly impacted by the international laws such as the rule of 1989 by the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and the 1998 rule of Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.... The old patterns of juvenile justice in the United States, major changes in the system and the impact of international laws and the United States criminal justice system on the juvenile justice of the U....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us