StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

First Amendment Hypothetical (LAW & ETHICS OF DIGITAL MEDIA) - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
s Instructor Date First Amendment Hypothetical (Law & Ethics of Digital Media) There are a number of legal issues that are relevant in the case against Fred White and are bound to be dealt with in a trial. The first issue is the topic of free speech/freedom of expression and the boundaries that an individual has when exercising this right…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
First Amendment Hypothetical (LAW & ETHICS OF DIGITAL MEDIA)
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "First Amendment Hypothetical (LAW & ETHICS OF DIGITAL MEDIA)"

s First Amendment Hypothetical (Law & Ethics of Digital Media) There are a number of legal issues that are relevant in the case against Fred White and are bound to be dealt with in a trial. The first issue is the topic of free speech/freedom of expression and the boundaries that an individual has when exercising this right. This can be said to be the main issue that the courts will deal with as they try to determine whether Mr. White’s actions fall under free speech and the boundaries that have been set for it.

Once in trial, the defense will no doubt attempt to argue that the accused was just practicing his right of freedom of expression and simply offering his opinion on a subject to those who would listen to him thus he has done no wrong (Rosen). On the other hand, the prosecution will attempt to prove that the actions of Mr. White went past his rights in the first amendment due to the nature of the information that he dealt with and therefore he should be punished in accordance to the law. The other legal issue that may be faced in this trial has to do with the matter of jurisdiction.

This is to say that whether the prosecution can prove in what jurisdiction was the alleged crime truly committed and whether the accused can be prosecuted according to the laws of that jurisdiction. This is because the said crime was committed over the internet (also known as cyberspace) and thus one may argue that the traditional laws that hold individuals in physical locations should not be applied to those involved in cyberspace as technically they are two different jurisdictions (Lessig, Post & Volokh).. This is because the internet has the ability to connect people all over the world thus one cannot truly say what section of people are truly affected by information that has been posted on to the world wide web.

Another legal issue that may be encountered during this trial is the issue of incitement. This will also be one of the charges that the prosecution will most likely try to accuse the defendant with on the grounds of his posts. The prosecution will try to prove that Mr. White did more than just offer his opinion on a subject but as a matter of fact, in the process of doing so was also attempting to incite the members of his audience into action by posting the type of material that he did on his blog.

The issue of slander will also come up during the court case as the prosecution will no doubt state that by giving his opinion on the judge in question, he did it in a manner that painted the victim in an unfairly negative light (Lessig, Post & Volokh).. The prosecution may argue that the accused made the judge seem incapable of performing his job to a sufficient capacity and as a result unnecessarily dragging his name through the mud. Once the case goes to trial, it will be unlikely that Mr.

White will be successful in defending his innocence by using the First Amendment rights in his argument. Though the first amendment offers it protection to people so that one is able to speak their mind without the fear of negative repercussions, there are also limits to the freedom of speech that is offered to a citizen. In a rough conclusion, the first amendment allows one to say what they want as long as their actions do not cause harm or risk doing so to another individual in the process (Lessig, Post & Volokh).

In the case of Mr. White and the judge involved, this cannot be said to have been the case. This is because the blogger’s comments may have in actuality put the life of the judge at risk especially with phrases such as “this judge should be killed” and “the judge’s blood is a tiny price to pay to guarantee freedom for all.” Which seem as if the writer is not only condoning an act of violence on the judge should one happen, but is actually promoting it by calling it a “tiny price” and a guarantee for freedom to all.

These words cannot be seen as the mere opinion of an individual but a move of incitement that may have put the judge’s life in danger. His argument based on the First amendment will also be foiled due to the addition of the extra material Mr. White posted on to his blog in addition to his rants about the judge. These included information on the judge such as maps of the judge’s home as well as of the courthouse at where he worked as well as a photograph of the judge himself. This material can be considered to be as a form of encouragement to his audience to fulfill the blogger’s comments on what the judge deserved.

In conclusion, Mr. White would not be able to use the first amendment effectively in his defense as his comments could be considered as a true threat towards the judge. Works Cited Larry Lessig, David Post & Eugene Volokh. Government as Sovereign – Three levels Protection: Part 1. Social Science Electronic Publishing, 1999. Web. February 7, 2013. http://www.ics.uci.edu/%7Ekay/computer.law/cyberlawcourse/lessons/fresp04.html. Larry Lessig, David Post & Eugene Volokh. Annoying/Offensive/Harassing Speech, Part 1.

Social Science Electronic Publishing, 1999. Web. February 7, 2013. http://www.ics.uci.edu/%7Ekay/computer.law/cyberlawcourse/lessons/fresp10.html. Larry Lessig, David Post & Eugene Volokh. Annoying/Offensive/Harassing Speech, Part 2. Social Science Electronic Publishing, 1999. Web. February 7, 2013. http://www.ics.uci.edu/%7Ekay/computer.law/cyberlawcourse/lessons/fresp11.html. Larry Lessig, David Post & Eugene Volokh. Annoying/Offensive/Harassing Speech, Part 4. Social Science Electronic Publishing, 1999. Web. February 7, 2013.

http://www.ics.uci.edu/%7Ekay/computer.law/cyberlawcourse/lessons/fresp13.html. Jay Rosen (May 31st 2007). A Blog Is Just a Little First Ammendment Machine. Huffington Post. Web. February 7, 2013. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jay-rosen/a-blog-is-a-little-first-_b_50164.html.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“First Amendment Hypothetical (LAW & ETHICS OF DIGITAL MEDIA) Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1467664-first-amendment-hypothetical-law-ethics-of-digital
(First Amendment Hypothetical (LAW & ETHICS OF DIGITAL MEDIA) Essay)
https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1467664-first-amendment-hypothetical-law-ethics-of-digital.
“First Amendment Hypothetical (LAW & ETHICS OF DIGITAL MEDIA) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1467664-first-amendment-hypothetical-law-ethics-of-digital.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF First Amendment Hypothetical (LAW & ETHICS OF DIGITAL MEDIA)

Law and Ethics of Digital Media: Privacy Law Hypothetical

Lecturer's Name and Number Date Submitted Law and ethics of digital media: Privacy Law Hypothetical Privacy law concerns regulations of an individual's personal information that can be accessed, used or retrieved by the government or other parties such as private organizations.... Courts in the United States, for a long time, have debated on whether the government can access information stored on digital media without breaching Amendment IV of the US constitution; if such information provides evidence of an unlawful activity (Lessig, Post and Volokh)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Freedom of Expression, First Amendment

first amendment (University) and number) (Date submitted) first amendment The freedom of expression is a constitutional right as provided by the first amendment of the US Constitution.... The first amendment, which was implemented in 1791, stated that the congress would not create any law respecting formation of religion, or barring the open exercise thereof; or shortening the openness of speech, or of the press; or the moral of the citizens peaceably to collect, and to request the Government for a redress of complaints....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

LAW AND ETHICS OF DIGITAL MEDIA HYPOTHETICAL: COPYRIGHT

Analyze YouTube's argument that it has complied with the digital Millennium Copyright Act.... Analyze Rita Espinoza's argument that her inclusion of Tito Puente's music in her video is a fair use.... Thinking about the concept of fair use, is her argument legitimate?... What evidence might she use to back her claim?...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The First Amendment

The first amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America represented the first ratification to the Constitution.... It states:… Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the Freedom of Speech or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances The first amendment speaks to the very heart of what it means to be an American....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Analysis of the Bill of Rights

Using this experience as their guide, the constitutional fathers wrote into their new Constitution a Bill of Rights, which contained the first amendment. The Bill of Rights consists of the first ten amendments, which contain procedural and substantive guarantees of individual liberties and limits upon government control and intervention.... The first amendment, perhaps the best known of these freedoms and protections, prohibits the establishment of a state-supported church, requires the separation of church and state, and guarantees freedom of worship, of speech and the press, the rights of peaceable assembly, association and petition....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Canon Law & 8th Amendment

Canon law is the body of officially established rules governing the faith and practice of the members of a Christian church.... Any church's or religion's laws, rules, and regulations; more commonly, the written policies that guide the administration and religious ceremonies of the Roman Catholic Church is the Canon law. … Amendment VIII (the Eighth Amendment) of the United States Constitution, which is part of the U.... These regulations are called canons and are codified in the Code of Canon law (in Latin, Codex juris canonici)....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Media Ethics IssueFinal

ven the fact that journalism is the only private trade that is explicitly recognized by the constitution in many countries, such as the first amendment in the US constitution, the relationship between the fourth estate and government remains a thorny one.... Matters of public interest such as official misappropriation of public funds and corruption may not see the light of day through the media since there is a difficult choice between the potential damage it can do to the persons mentioned if in the end proved not to be true....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

General Theory of the First Amendment

This paper ''first amendment'' tells that the first amendment of the United States Constitution is the amendment that provides the rights and freedoms that the USA citizens should enjoy without interference from the state, reinforcing the provisions o the bill of rights.... hellip; The first amendment covers all activities at the federal, state and local government levels, and all such levels of government are bound by the amendment, which takes preference over any other local legislation that could speak to the same subject enacted at those levels....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us