StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author analyzes the article which has examined Singapore Airlines’ success; it explored how SIA was able to stand against other competitors. The Authors proclaimed that SIA has achieved exceptional performance and constantly is taking advantage of its competitive advantage. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success"

Introduction: The chosen article has examined Singapore Airlines’ success; it explored how SIA was able to stand against other competitors. The s proclaimed that SIA has achieved an exceptional performance and constantly is taking advantage from its competitive advantage. The Authors (relying on facts and data from different sources, also using different methodologies) argued that SIA has successfully applied a strategy which was dual: differentiation through excellence, service and innovation, alongside with cost leadership in its strategic planning. Importantly, the authors also investigated the organizational factors that have facilitated SIA’s chance to implement its inspirations; they used the method of illustrating its strategic position. Finally, they drew their conclusions and explored the prospective challenges for SIA. Reviewing the structure and contents of the article: The authors reviewed the available literature that investigated the differentiation and cost leadership, they referred to the work of (Porter, 1985) who claimed that differentiation and cost leadership has to be mutually exclusive as they require various kinds of investments across the value chain. Porter’s recognized generic strategy framework and suggests that companies when looking for sustainable competitive advantage they must choose between a cost-leadership or differentiation approach, alongside with a preference about the scope of the market they are seeking to compete in. Porter argued that if a company tries to apply both would lead to inconsistency and the achievement of neither strategy. And as a result the company would be “stuck in the middle” (Porter, 1985). Since each selection should be supported and applied through relevant resource allocation decisions and other strategic actions. However, the authors have argued that SIA has effectively blended differentiation regarding market positioning and quality of offering, with a low-cost strategy regarding internal operational costs to achieve greater results. Indeed, both advanced quality and high levels of efficiency have been part of the aims and objectives of SIA since its creation, there purpose was to: offer the top-notch quality of customer service that is safe, reliable and economical; produce earnings that offer enough resources for investment and sufficient returns to shareholders; offer human resource management that intrigues, increase, inspire and retain employees who contribute to the company’s objectives; and exploit productivity and utilization of all resources, (Wirtz, Heracleous and Pangarkar 2008). The authors have used several of resources and different methodologies; the most important among them is the interviews with experts which significantly helped to draw their conclusions and outcomes. Additionally to examining database resources on SIA and the airline industry, authors have undertaken 18 in-depth interviews. The authors argued that the interview data have given them an opportunity to achieve a greater understanding of how SIA has applied its operations and internal processes to improve the main competency of cost-effective service excellence, attain sustainable competitive advantage and surpass other airlines for a long time. Authors have transcribed and analyzed these interviews to determine procedures and general themes and then they discussed them and drew the outcomes and conclusions. The selected case study ‘Singapore Airlines’ was researched for over seven years and it investigated the company’s strategy and competitiveness, specifically its organizational competencies which influenced the delivery of service excellence in a cost-effective manner. Then the article examined how these competencies are expanded and sustained by SIA’s operational configurations and functional strategies, examples of supportive sectors; the human resource planning and internal innovation developments. The authors collected both primary and secondary data in relation to the relevant areas. Authors started their article with defining the market, they referred to relevant market data to do this, and then they defined the company’s position in the market. However, whether they used the relevant data and whether they said on what basis they are positioning the company is the rational of this essay. When they defined the market they mentioned the different levels including socio-economic factors which can affect the aviation industry. They named factors such as increasing oil prices, the pandemic crisis, i.e. bird flu, the Asian tsunami, and rising terrorism and stated that these can negatively affect the profitability side. Based on IATA they said that in 2006, the global airlines industry suffered a net loss of $500m, or 0.1% of revenues, accumulating net losses of $42bn between 2001 and 2006 (International Air Transport Association, 2007). However, in 2007, the airline industry made a reasonable net profit of $5.6bn on revenues of $490bn, equivalent to less than 2% margin (International Air Transport Association, 2008). Following to the definition of the market the authors have tried to position SIA in the relevant industry environment. They mentioned the reasons why Singapore Airlines has constantly surpassed its competitors. According to the authors SIA has never posted a loss on an annual basis, and has successfully attained a considerable and higher return compared to its industry, and has received hundreds of industry awards for its service quality. The article justified this on the fact that SIA has successfully accomplished its exceptional performance by applying a dual strategy: differentiation in the course of service superiority and innovation, along with simultaneous cost leadership in its associated group. These are actually the main themes which were discussed in the article. It is important to note at this stage that the article has considerably provided a very strong argument that SIA succeeded when applied dual strategy. However, it did not contrast their arguments against other rival’s strategies. If they compare SIA with others, this could show the quality of using dual strategy. Also, it will present the weaknesses of other companies having not applied SIA’s distinguished strategy. Singapore Airlines is positioned as a finest carrier with high levels of innovation and outstanding levels of service. SIA applied a strategic choice of giving priority to profitability over size. The internal organizational practices, such as constant employee development and rigorous service design are central aspects of operational zing and sustaining this positioning and strategic choice. These themes were critically discussed throughout the article. With regard to corporate issue, SIA adopts a strategy of related diversification. The Singapore Airlines Group has 36 subsidiaries and associated companies (Singapore Airlines, 2008). According to (Doganis, 2006), through SIA’s strategy the use of information technology is a crucial element which helps to develop customer service, also SIA’s web site is one of the most superior and user friendly sites in the aviation industry, efficient use of IT can considerably decrease costs and improve service levels. In terms of business planning strategy, Singapore Airlines has managed to offer finest service to very demanding customers. The authors at this point argued that this aspect indicates to the achievement of ‘differentiation’. Therefore, they contrasted Porter’s recommendations that differentiation and cost leadership are mutually exclusive strategies. Authors therefore observed that Singapore Airlines applied dual strategy of differentiation and internal cost leadership. Any airline tries to apply service excellence and efficiency, but sometimes this is difficult to do. For example, Malaysian airlines has a very good service but the efficiency is not very well (Doganis, 2006). The article identified five essential components of SIA’s organizational activity arrangement, which are namely; rigorous service design and development, total innovation, profit consciousness ingrained in all employees, achieving strategic synergies, and developing staff holistically. 1) SIA awakes that to keep up its differentiation, it must sustain constant improvement, and is ready to rescind any schemes or services that no longer offer competitive differentiation or that could be offered in a different way. 2) Innovation is a main concern of SIA, “we just have to be better than our competitors in everything we do. Just a little bit better in everything. This allows us to make a small profit from the flight to enable us to innovate without pricing ourselves out of the market.’’ The previous is a statement of a senior manager at SIA (Yap Kim Wah). He further stated: ‘‘It is getting more and more difficult to differentiate ourselves because every airline is doing the same thing...the crucial fact is that we continue to say that we want to improve…that we have the will to do so. And that every time we reach a goal, we always say that we got to find a new mountain or hill to climb. You must be able to give up what you love’’. (Yap Kim Wah). Therefore, SIA is continuously tries to develop its innovation strategy to compete with other rival in the aviation industry. 3) SIA does not aim to be a largest company. But they want be the most profitable. SIA is claimed to have the second highest market capitalization in the airline industry internationally (after Southwest), despite the fact that its revenues are relatively modest compared to competitors such as the Air France–KLM Group, British Airways, or the Lufthansa Group. Therefore, a central objective of SIA is to make profit rather than being a huge company with high revenue but less profit. 4) SIA focuses to constantly produce skillful persons, all employees, no matter how higher are they, have to do a training and development plan with clear objectives. The well-known ‘‘Singapore Girl’’ go through training for 15 weeks, longer than any other airline and approximately twice as long as the industry average of 2 months. The required training includes not just functional skills such as food and beverage serving and safety training. It however, includes also range skills of personal interaction, personal poise, grooming and deportment, and emotional skills. 5) Dual strategy of differentiation and cost leadership (which is the main issue discussed in the article). Conclusion: Generally speaking the article is very rigorous in some aspects such as the exploration of SIA strategy in terms of corporate level and business level. In this regard the article offered excellent ranges of data and explanation based on different sources, material and methodologies. However, the article clearly has some weaknesses. Firstly, one must not ignore that fact that when the authors tried to position SIA in the market the omitted to provide the reader with relevant data from other rivals. They did not compare for example the profitability of SIA against other competitive rivals i.e. BA. Furthermore, one must note that the authors have not sufficiently explained SIA’s human resources development strategy which has greatly benefited the airline and helped to provide excellent services. On earlier article in 2008, they have broadly explained how important is the HRM for the increasing the efficiency, i.e. cost-effective service excellence. Previously, they also referred to the additional feature of human resource management practices and the resulting quality of human resources is that they are difficult for competitors to replicate, (Wirtz, Heracleous and Pangarkar 2008). More important is the rational of the article which is the excellent service and innovation. Authors could have done better if they explained and compared these themes against other rivals. They only provided information related to SIA. They tried to justify that by applying these methods and schemes SIA has achieved great results. However, it is a good idea to show the strengths of SIA against other rival’s weaknesses. They could have illustrated other rival’s plans which were applied but failed. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success Term Paper, n.d.)
Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success Term Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1560530-researsh-methods-critical-review
(Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success Term Paper)
Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/business/1560530-researsh-methods-critical-review.
“Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success Term Paper”. https://studentshare.org/business/1560530-researsh-methods-critical-review.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Review of the Article about Singapore Airlines Success

Is Fuel Price Hedging Profitable for Airline Industries

Hedging basically fastens airlines cost of future fuel purchases.... (Morell & Swan) Other costs are less unstable… More constant costs also mean more stable profits and higher equity values for shareholders The theory behind airline fuel hedges is to lessen a major swing in profit, and thus better returns for the airline Most airlines today hedge fuel costs.... The state of the capital markets has not been too rosy itself leaving many corporations without much access to capital let alone cheaper rates In these times of significant modification and instability, it is a need that these airlines employ a feasible risk management program, allowing not only confronting the most challenging of times, but should also lead them to prosper in face of adversities....
12 Pages (3000 words) Article

Speech word to word

The award essentially recognizes and celebrates firms which have attained major success in their alliances and… The judges established that Northwest/KLM has shown true commitment to advancing and sharing alliance management practices in their relationship, which has led to tangible business results by means of alliance innovation and implementation (EasierTravel). The Speech Presentation The strategic alliance between Northwest Airlines and Royal Dutch KLM The strategic alliance between KLM Royal Dutch Airlines andNorthwest Airlines was awarded the global 2007 Association of Strategic Alliance Professionals (ASAP) Award....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Whatever the artical is talking about something over

In this article, Leovy (2015) addresses a major weakness of the American justice system that has led to a proliferation of homicides among the black Americans.... Apparently, the police, which is part of the criminal justice system, has failed to address this problem effectively.... hellip; cording to Leovy (2015), the police are not doing enough because they are focusing more on prevention of crime in this community and less on arresting and bringing the criminals to justice....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Business and Service Marketing

ingapore airlines (SIA), one of the leading airlines of the world, is aware that they cannot afford to be complacent in the face of stiff competition.... Customer expectations and demand forces them to constantly review and change their strategy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Revenue Management, Implementation and Preconditions

Then it will take a deeper review of the implementation of YM through models and the impacts of the external factors and SWOT analysis of such system within the two different industries.... Consequently, it spread among the researchers, airlines, consulting firms and other organizations to develop and to yield profit from this area.... Studies have cited that the RM has evolved over 30 years ago, in the early 70s Littlewood and Rothstein have explored the revenue management practice in the airlines and hotels....
17 Pages (4250 words) Article

Quality Management of Flagship Airline Company of UAE

The company is the largest airlines company in the Middle East.... The subsidiary of a renowned group that is the Emirates Group is the airlines Emirates.... hellip; The researcher states that airlines Emirates is Flagship Airline Company of UAE mainly undertaken by the government of UAE.... In-spite of its competitive prices, the Emirates airlines introduced excellent flight operations and numerous long haul flights that proved extremely effective for the organization thereby amplifying its profitability and reliability as compared to others....
12 Pages (3000 words) Article

Southwest Airlines Co

he author has taken an objective approach towards the topic, with a clear review of both the internal and external factors within the business environment that may affect performance (Abdelghany & Abdelghany, 2012).... rdquo; aims at informing a reader that both the internal and external factors within a business environment ought to be considered before laying strategies that would facilitate the success of a business within the market.... rdquo; by MarketLine, reviews both the internal and external factors that affect the success of the company....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us